How a provider gets its score
Two numbers, produced by two separate processes. The Ratedd score measures a provider's record against every other scored provider. The due diligence score measures how much of the business behind it we could verify. Neither is averaged into the other.
Version 3.1 · in force since Jul 1, 2026
Ratedd score
0–100 · 8 weighted factors
What the signals did, how quickly they could be acted on, what access costs against the return, and what subscribers and our own test enquiries found.
Due diligence
0–100 · 8 checks
Checks on the business behind the signals, published as findings and not only as a number.
Recalculated
Every Monday, 06:00 UTC
Each weekly pass is reviewed before it is published, so scores and ranks move only when one is. A diligence finding is published as soon as it is saved.
The Ratedd score
Weights sum to 100
16% of the score
Profit factor
Gross winning R ÷ gross losing R
Every closed signal in the record, in R-multiples, not a selected sample. A signal that is still open, or never filled, has no result and is left out. A ratio above 10, or a record with no losing close, counts as 10.
Full history · decayed
14% of the score
Win rate
Share of closed signals in profit
A signal wins when it closes with a positive realised R. A break-even close counts as a loss.
Full history · decayed
14% of the score
Risk-reward
Mean winning R ÷ mean losing R
Measured on the realised exit, not the posted target. With win rate it makes up profit factor exactly, so the three read one record from three sides. A ratio above 10, or a record with no losing close, counts as 10.
Full history · decayed
14% of the score
Consistency
Monthly return dispersion
The standard deviation of audited monthly returns, where lower is better, with the number of positive months carrying 50% of the factor. Needs at least 6 months with a return entered.
Rolling 24m
12% of the score
Delivery to entry
Median time from post to fill
Timed from a signal's publication to the first fillable price, with the share of signals that became fillable at all carrying 50% of the factor. A signal that never became fillable counts as a miss.
Rolling 90d
12% of the score
Cost vs. performance
Annualised return per dollar of monthly cost
The mean monthly return, annualised without compounding, divided by the monthly subscription fee. Broker-linked access charges no fee and counts as 10, the ceiling. A provider with no positive return takes the bottom of the factor, whatever it charges.
Current terms
10% of the score
Subscriber satisfaction
Mean verified star rating
Ratings subscribers send us, counted only once our team has reviewed and accepted each one.
Rolling 12m
8% of the score
Support responsiveness
Median first-reply time
Measured on our own test enquiries, sent unannounced from ordinary subscriber accounts, with the share answered at all carrying 50% of the factor. An enquiry still awaiting a reply does not count yet.
Rolling 90d
100Total
Normalisation
Each factor is a percentile from 0 to 100 against the providers that are scored, not an absolute target, so a provider in the middle of the field on a factor scores 50 on it. Unscored providers do not move the scale. Values are first held inside the field's own p2 and p98, so one extreme figure cannot set the scale for everyone else. Where a factor measures two things, each is ranked on its own and then blended. There is no minimum field size: with few providers, each step in a percentile is large.
Eligibility
A provider is scored only when it clears every floor below. Short of any one, it is listed as Unscored: its record is shown, without a score or a rank. A missing factor is never filled in, and the other weights are never stretched to cover it.
- 6calendar months holding a closed signal · Full history
- 150closed signals · Full history
- 6months with an audited return entered · Rolling 24m
- 10accepted subscriber ratings · Rolling 12m
- 3test enquiries answered or closed as unanswered · Rolling 90d
Decay
Signals that closed in the last 12 months carry full weight. Older signals lose weight steadily until 36 months, and keep 40% from then on, so a long record still counts but not as much as current form. Decay applies to Profit factor, Win rate, and Risk-reward. The other factors are measured over a rolling window, which already favours recent form.
What a number means
A band is a range of the score, not a share of providers.
90–100
Top decile
Near the top of the field on almost every factor. Because every factor is a percentile, this band can be empty.
75–89
Strong
Ahead of most of the field on most factors.
55–74
Mixed
Around the middle of the field, with strengths and weaknesses that roughly balance.
Below 55
Weak
Behind most of the field on most factors.
Due diligence
Each check is worth an equal share of the score, 12.5 points out of 100.
Scored separately · never folded into the Ratedd score
- Pass earns 100% of its share
- Partial earns 50% of its share
- Fail earns 0% of its share
- A check we have not run earns nothing.
Regulated entity
Who the counterparty is, where it is registered, and whether the activity it performs requires a licence it does not hold.
Registry filings
Team identity
Whether the people behind the signals are named and identifiable, or the business is anonymous.
ID verification
Read-only audit
Whether we hold live read-only credentials, and whether the trade record is continuous from the date access began.
Live account access
Broker disclosure
Whether rebate or referral arrangements with a broker exist, and whether the provider discloses them to subscribers.
Agreements, account data
Access terms
What is required to receive signals, what ends access, and whether stated refund or exit terms are honoured in practice.
Sampled cases
Complaint history
Unresolved complaints across public forums, regulators and payment disputes over the past 24 months.
Public record
Claims vs. results
Whether marketing figures match the audited record. Any material gap is published as a finding.
Site copy vs. audit
Tamper checks
Whether trades have been edited, deleted or back-dated in the account record.
Ledger diff
A fail on Regulated entity, Read-only audit, or Tamper checks holds the tier at Limited or below, whatever the score.
Full review
85–100Nearly every check passed, and no check that caps the tier failed.
Partial
70–84Most checks passed, with findings published on the report.
Limited
45–69Significant gaps, or a check that caps the tier failed.
Unchecked
Below 45Little of the business could be verified.
Where the data comes from
The signal record
Each signal's publication, fill and close, with its realised result in R, entered by our team. Where we hold read-only access to the provider's account the record is checked against it and the report marks it Verified. Otherwise it is self-reported, and ranked on the same terms.
Feeds Profit factor, Win rate, Risk-reward, and Delivery to entry
Monthly statements
Each month's return, entered by our team from the provider's account statement. A signal records no position size, so returns are never worked out from signals.
Feeds Consistency
Access terms
What a subscriber pays and what access requires, as the provider currently states it.
Feeds Cost vs. performance
Subscriber ratings
Star ratings subscribers send us through our submission form. Each is reviewed by our team before it counts.
Feeds Subscriber satisfaction
Test enquiries
Enquiries we send unannounced from ordinary subscriber accounts. We time the first reply, and record an enquiry that is never answered.
Feeds Support responsiveness
Public and registry record
Company filings, regulator registers, payment disputes and complaints. Each check names the evidence it rests on.
Feeds the due diligence score
What we do not do
- Accept payment to raise, delay or withhold a score.
- Let a provider see its score before it is published.
- Fold the due diligence result into the Ratedd score, or the reverse.
- Score a provider on fewer than all of its factors.
- Remove a published score because the provider asked.
Cadence, changes and conflicts
Weekly
Score recalculation
A scoring pass runs every Monday at 06:00 UTC across every tracked provider. Our team reviews it before it is published, and until then no published score or rank changes.
Every 6 months
Diligence review
A provider's file falls due for review 6 months after its last audit. The score and tier its findings imply are published with the next scoring pass.
v3.1
Methodology changes
Weight changes are announced 30 days before they take effect. Every published score keeps the weights it was calculated under, so an old score still explains itself.
Conflicts
Commercial arrangements
Rank is set by the score alone. Every input to the score is listed on this page, and none of them is anything a provider pays us.
Disagree with a figure?
Send us the underlying account data. If a figure in the record is wrong, we correct it, and the score moves with the next published scoring pass. We do not remove a score because a provider asked.
Submit a correction